The Gospel of Johns relationship to the Synoptic Gospels is a perennial question. For centuries, the Gospel of Matthew has been considered the least likely of possible written sources of the Fourth Gospel. In an ambitious reappraisal, James Barker demonstrates Johns use of the redacted Gospel of Matthew.
After reviewing the history of interpretation on the question, Barker develops three case studies. Concerning ecclesial authority, Barker contends that Johns saying concerning forgiving and retaining sins derives from Matthews binding and loosing logion. Regarding proof from prophecy, he argues that John relies on Matthew for Zechariahs oracle about Israels king entering Jerusalem on a donkey.
Finally, he argues that Johns inclusion of Samaritans contrasts sharply with Matthews exclusion of Samaritans from the early church. Although Johns engagement with Matthew was by no means uncritical, Barker at last concludes that John intended his Gospel to be read alongside, not instead of, Matthews.
